The Economic and Political Weekly, the most academic magazine in India, has published a review of Lal Khan's book, "Partition - can it be undone?", written by Ranabir Samaddar. He gives a positive appraisal of the book and asks a pertinent question at the end: "But are the official communists listening to all these?"
West Bengal has been governed for many years by
the Left Front, whose main component is the CPI(M), one of India’s main
Communist Parties. Their past is one of support for Stalinism. Today the
leaders of this party have transferred their allegiance to so-called
“neo-liberal” capitalism, to the degree that they have actively organised
brutal attacks on peasants defending their land from being taken from them.
The dalits, the “untouchables”, of India are not one
homogenous bloc. Within them a bourgeois layer has risen and aspires to be a
part of the bourgeois class as a whole. With this aim in mind they promote the
idea that the dalits as a caste need their own “dalit party”. To do this they
try to isolate the dalit proletariat from the rest of the Indian working class
to promote their own selfish interests. Here Rajesh Tyagi explains that what is
needed is proletarian unity across the caste barriers.